The Lions have had a fantastic start to the 2024-2025 year with more than fifteen athletes being selected to a fall All-Catholic team. O'Hara's athletes that were selected to an All-Catholic team includes:

Golf

Alaina Carson

Girls Soccer

Kaelynn Dienna- 2nd Team

Brigid MacGilivray- 3rd Team

Penny Miller- 3rd Team

Girls Tennis

Kayla Stewart- 1st Team Singles

Allison Kirby- 2nd Team Singles

Martha Coffey and Allison Lorenz- 1st Team Doubles

Cross Country

Monica Grosso- 2nd Team

Volleyball

Michelle Eburuoh- 1st Team

Julia Riley- 1st Team

Bridget O'Reilly- 1st Team

Kerigan Patterson- 2nd Team

Ashlynn Gualtieri- 3rd Team

Boys Soccer

Zydan Stewart- 2nd Team

Field Hockey

Maddie Fagioli- 1st Team

Kara McLaughlin- 1st Team

Tori Pagliotti- 3rd Team